Hemangioma vs melanoma is a frequent referral question when an orange or nonpigmented choroidal mass appears near the macula.

Circumscribed choroidal hemangioma is a benign vascular hamartoma, but amelanotic melanoma can look strikingly similar. Therefore, the decision rests on color, ultrasound, angiography and growth.


Why Hemangioma vs Melanoma Causes Confusion

Both tumors arise in the choroid and can cause subretinal fluid, and many melanomas carry little pigment. Meanwhile, overlying RPE hyperplasia can darken part of a hemangioma, so color alone may mislead experienced examiners.

Patient Profile and Symptoms

Hemangioma usually presents in middle age with blurred vision, metamorphopsia or a hyperopic shift from macular fluid, while melanoma also affects adults, especially those with fair skin and light irides. However, small melanomas are often asymptomatic and found on routine examination, so the history rarely settles the diagnosis.

Test your knowledge 10 questions from this article
Choroida · Fundus imaging

Fundus Explorer Pro

Photograph the retinal findings described here with the phone already in your pocket — 22 D optics and built-in illumination in one handheld unit.

From Choroida — the team behind this site

Color in Hemangioma vs Melanoma

A typical hemangioma is reddish orange, and its margins blend gradually into the normal fundus. By contrast, an amelanotic melanoma usually looks yellow, tan or creamy, often with mottled brown areas. Also, surface clumps of orange lipofuscin favor melanoma (see choroidal nevus vs small melanoma).

Shape and Location

Hemangiomas sit mostly in the posterior pole, often near the disc or fovea, and form a smooth, low dome a few millimeters thick. Melanoma can occur anywhere and may break through Bruch membrane, and that mushroom shape essentially excludes hemangioma.

Ultrasound in Hemangioma vs Melanoma

Ultrasound is the most useful single office test, and on B-scan and A-scan, a hemangioma shows uniform high internal reflectivity from its many vascular interfaces. Melanoma, however, shows low to medium internal reflectivity, acoustic hollowness, choroidal excavation and sometimes orbital shadowing, and then record thickness and basal diameter at every visit.

Fluorescein Angiography Findings

On FA, a hemangioma fills very early, often in the prearterial or arterial phase, with a lacy vascular pattern, and late frames then show diffuse staining. In contrast, a melanoma fills more slowly and patchily, and larger tumors may show a double circulation, but overlap is considerable, so FA rarely decides the case alone.

ICG Pattern in Hemangioma vs Melanoma

Indocyanine green angiography gives the most characteristic sign, because a hemangioma fills rapidly and intensely within the first minute. Then, in late frames, the dye washes out and the lesion turns relatively hypofluorescent. Melanoma usually fills slowly and variably, without this early bright, late washout sequence.

OCT and the Overlying Retina

Over a hemangioma, OCT often shows chronic intraretinal cysts and retinal edema, while melanoma more often shows fresh subretinal fluid with shaggy, elongated photoreceptors. Also, enhanced depth imaging may reveal large choroidal vessels inside a hemangioma, but these patterns overlap, so OCT supports the other tests.

Hemangioma vs Melanoma (Choroid Tumors): How to Tell

Growth in Hemangioma vs Melanoma

Hemangiomas usually remain stable in size over long follow-up, and vision falls because of fluid while the tumor itself barely changes. Therefore, documented enlargement of a choroidal mass should raise strong concern for melanoma.

Other Mimics to Exclude

Several lesions also enter this differential:

  • Choroidal metastasis, creamy yellow and often multifocal
  • Choroidal osteoma, with bright plate-like echoes
  • Posterior scleritis, with a T-sign on ultrasound
  • Melanocytoma, dark and usually at the disc

Treatment in Hemangioma vs Melanoma

Symptomatic hemangioma is usually treated with verteporfin photodynamic therapy (see choroidal hemangioma). PDT dries the macula and often flattens the tumor, but it cannot reverse chronic photoreceptor loss.

Melanoma, however, needs plaque brachytherapy, proton beam therapy or enucleation (see choroidal melanoma). As a result, PDT for a misdiagnosed melanoma could delay effective treatment.

Counseling the Patient

Patients often hear the word tumor and assume cancer, so for hemangioma, explain that the lesion is benign and threatens vision only through fluid. Suspected melanoma, by contrast, calls for referral to an ocular oncologist and a discussion of systemic surveillance, and when doubt persists, say so and explain the monitoring plan.

Follow-Up Plan

First, document the lesion with photography, OCT and ultrasound at baseline, and next, recheck any uncertain lesion within a few months. Finally, growth, new orange pigment or new fluid should trigger urgent oncology referral.

Quick Table: Hemangioma vs Melanoma

  • Color: reddish orange versus tan, yellow or mottled
  • Ultrasound: high versus low to medium internal reflectivity
  • Shape: low dome versus dome or mushroom
  • ICG: early intense filling with late washout versus slow filling
  • Growth: stable versus progressive

Pitfalls to Avoid

  • Do not diagnose hemangioma on color alone
  • Never start PDT for an orange mass without ultrasound
  • Also, remember that RPE hyperplasia can darken a hemangioma
  • Refer early when imaging findings conflict

All-fit smartphone adapter on a slit lampFundus Explorer Pro smartphone fundus camera
Choroida · Clinical imaging

Document what you see

Two smartphone imaging tools built for everyday clinic use — one for the slit lamp, one for the fundus.

From Choroida — the team behind this site

References

  1. Shields CL, Honavar SG, Shields JA, Cater J, Demirci H. Circumscribed choroidal hemangioma: clinical manifestations and factors predictive of visual outcome in 200 consecutive cases. Ophthalmology. 2001;108:2237-2248.
  2. Shields JA, Zimmerman LE. Lesions simulating malignant melanoma of the posterior uvea. Arch Ophthalmol. 1973;89:466-471.
  3. Shields CL, Shields JA, De Potter P. Patterns of indocyanine green videoangiography of choroidal tumours. Br J Ophthalmol. 1995;79:237-245.
  4. Shields CL, Manalac J, Das C, Ferguson K, Shields JA. Choroidal melanoma: clinical features, classification, and top 10 pseudomelanomas. Curr Opin Ophthalmol. 2014;25:177-185.
  5. Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study Group. Accuracy of diagnosis of choroidal melanomas in the Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study. COMS report no. 1. Arch Ophthalmol. 1990;108:1268-1273.

Test yourself

A few questions straight from this article.

1 / 10 0 correct
  1. What is a circumscribed choroidal hemangioma?

Ahmed Ophthalmologist

Writes and reviews the clinical articles on Educate. Every post is checked against peer-reviewed sources before it goes live.